A/YL-NSW/293
Click here to view Applications at the Site/Building
Section 17 Review Application
Application No.
A/YL-NSW/293
Plan Area
Nam Sang Wai
District
Fanling, Sheung Shui & Yuen Long East District
Date of Application Received
20/02/2023
Nature of Review
To review the refusal decision of the application
Location
Various Lots in D.D. 103 and D.D. 115, Tung Shing Lei, Nam Sang Wai, Yuen Long
Proposal
Proposed Comprehensive Residential Development
Applicant's Submission
No softcopy provided by Applicant. Hardcopies available at Planning Enquiry Counters for inspection.
Newspaper Notice & Gist of Development Proposal (including Location Plan) (indicative only for section 12A application)
Newspaper Notice Download newspaper notice
Gist Download Gist
[Note: The Gist may be superseded by a new Gist if Further Information is received]
Expiry Date for Making Comments on Application (No. of Comments on Application Already Received)
24/03/2023 (11)
Application Available for Public Inspection Until (tentative date of meeting)
17/01/2025
Remark
Deferred on 22/03/2024
Deferred on 23/08/2024
| Nature | The applicant provided the first written submission supporting the review application. |
|---|---|
| Applicant's Submission | No softcopy provided by Applicant. Hardcopies available at Planning Enquiry Counters for inspection. |
| Decision |
Accepted but Not Exempted from Publication
Newspaper Notice Download newspaper notice Gist Download Gist [Note: The Gist may be superseded by a new Gist if Further Information is received] |
| No. of Comments on Further Information Already Received | 05/05/2023 (35) |
| Nature | The applicant submitted further information, including a revised master layout plan, a revised development parameters table and justifications for the revisions. |
|---|---|
| Applicant's Submission | No softcopy provided by Applicant. Hardcopies available at Planning Enquiry Counters for inspection. |
| Decision |
Accepted but Not Exempted from Publication
Newspaper Notice Download newspaper notice Gist Download Gist [Note: The Gist may be superseded by a new Gist if Further Information is received] |
| No. of Comments on Further Information Already Received | 14/07/2023 (9) |
| Nature | The applicant submitted further information including a table of responses to departmental comments, revised landscape master plan, revised internal transport facilities provision and review of environmental impacts. |
|---|---|
| Applicant's Submission | No softcopy provided by Applicant. Hardcopies available at Planning Enquiry Counters for inspection. |
| Decision |
Accepted but Not Exempted from Publication
Newspaper Notice Download newspaper notice Gist Download Gist [Note: The Gist may be superseded by a new Gist if Further Information is received] |
| No. of Comments on Further Information Already Received | 08/09/2023 (5) |
| Nature | The applicant provided further information which includes a table of responses to departmental comments, revised master layout plan, revised landscape master plan, updated review of environmental impacts and traffic generation and attraction. |
|---|---|
| Applicant's Submission | No softcopy provided by Applicant. Hardcopies available at Planning Enquiry Counters for inspection. |
| Decision |
Accepted but Not Exempted from Publication
Newspaper Notice Download newspaper notice Gist Download Gist [Note: The Gist may be superseded by a new Gist if Further Information is received] |
| No. of Comments on Further Information Already Received | 24/11/2023 (10) |
| Nature | The applicant provided further information which includes a table of responses to departmental comments, revised master layout plan, revised landscape plans and revised tree treatment/compensation plans. |
|---|---|
| Applicant's Submission | No softcopy provided by Applicant. Hardcopies available at Planning Enquiry Counters for inspection. |
| Decision |
Accepted but Not Exempted from Publication
Newspaper Notice Download newspaper notice Gist Download Gist [Note: The Gist may be superseded by a new Gist if Further Information is received] |
| No. of Comments on Further Information Already Received | 09/02/2024 (25) |
| Nature | The applicant provided further information which includes a table of responses to departmental comments, revised master layout plan, revised landscape plans and revised tree treatment/compensation plans. |
|---|---|
| Applicant's Submission | No softcopy provided by Applicant. Hardcopies available at Planning Enquiry Counters for inspection. |
| Decision | Accepted and Exempted from Publication |
| Nature | The applicant submitted supplementary information and justifications to support the review application. |
|---|---|
| Applicant's Submission | No softcopy provided by Applicant. Hardcopies available at Planning Enquiry Counters for inspection. |
| Decision | Accepted and Exempted from Publication |
| Nature | The applicant submitted justifications to support the review application. |
|---|---|
| Applicant's Submission | No softcopy provided by Applicant. Hardcopies available at Planning Enquiry Counters for inspection. |
| Decision | Accepted and Exempted from Publication |
Application No.
A/YL-NSW/293
Plan Area
Nam Sang Wai
District
Fanling, Sheung Shui & Yuen Long East District
Date of Application Received
06/10/2021
Location
Various Lots in D.D. 103 and D.D. 115, Tung Shing Lei, Nam Sang Wai, Yuen Long
Proposal
Proposed Comprehensive Residential Development
Applicant's Submission
No softcopy provided by Applicant. Hardcopies available at Planning Enquiry Counters for inspection.
Newspaper Notice & Gist of Development Proposal (including Location Plan) (indicative only for section 12A application)
Newspaper Notice Download newspaper notice
Gist Download Gist
[Note: The Gist may be superseded by a new Gist if Further Information is received]
Expiry Date for Making Comments on Application (No. of Comments on Application Already Received)
09/11/2021 (70)
Application Available for Public Inspection Until (tentative date of meeting)
03/02/2023
Remark
Deferred on 25/11/2022
| Nature | The applicant submitted a revised Air Ventilation Assessment. |
|---|---|
| Applicant's Submission | No softcopy provided by Applicant. Hardcopies available at Planning Enquiry Counters for inspection. |
| Decision |
Accepted but Not Exempted from Publication
Newspaper Notice Download newspaper notice Gist Download Gist [Note: The Gist may be superseded by a new Gist if Further Information is received] |
| No. of Comments on Further Information Already Received | 14/12/2021 (18) |
| Nature | The applicant submitted a table of responses to departmental comments, a revised Ecological Impact Assessment, Water Supply Impact Assessment, Landscape Proposal and Broad Technical Assessment on Rail Capacity of MTR West Rail Line. |
|---|---|
| Applicant's Submission | No softcopy provided by Applicant. Hardcopies available at Planning Enquiry Counters for inspection. |
| Decision |
Accepted but Not Exempted from Publication
Newspaper Notice Download newspaper notice Gist Download Gist [Note: The Gist may be superseded by a new Gist if Further Information is received] |
| No. of Comments on Further Information Already Received | 14/01/2022 (27) |
| Nature | The applicant submitted further information in response to departmental comments, sewerage impact assessment, drainage impact assessment, air ventilation assessment and visual impact assessment. |
|---|---|
| Applicant's Submission | No softcopy provided by Applicant. Hardcopies available at Planning Enquiry Counters for inspection. |
| Decision |
Accepted but Not Exempted from Publication
Newspaper Notice Download newspaper notice Gist Download Gist [Note: The Gist may be superseded by a new Gist if Further Information is received] |
| No. of Comments on Further Information Already Received | 11/02/2022 (21) |
| Nature | The applicant submitted further information in response to departmental comments with revised traffic impact assessment, revised public transport assessment, revised environmental assessment, revised visual impact assessment, revised air ventilation assessment, revised sewerage impact assessment, and revised landscape impact assessment. |
|---|---|
| Applicant's Submission | No softcopy provided by Applicant. Hardcopies available at Planning Enquiry Counters for inspection. |
| Decision |
Accepted but Not Exempted from Publication
Newspaper Notice Download newspaper notice Gist Download Gist [Note: The Gist may be superseded by a new Gist if Further Information is received] |
| No. of Comments on Further Information Already Received | 19/04/2022 (19) |
| Nature | The applicant submitted further information in response to departmental comments with revised ecological impact assessment, revised sewerage impact assessment, revised tree survey schedule, revised landscape proposal, revised air ventilation assessment, and replacement pages of the revised visual impact assessment. |
|---|---|
| Applicant's Submission | No softcopy provided by Applicant. Hardcopies available at Planning Enquiry Counters for inspection. |
| Decision |
Accepted but Not Exempted from Publication
Newspaper Notice Download newspaper notice Gist Download Gist [Note: The Gist may be superseded by a new Gist if Further Information is received] |
| No. of Comments on Further Information Already Received | 24/05/2022 (20) |
| Nature | The applicant submitted further information in response to departmental comments with proposed public transport (GMB) lay-by assessment, revised traffic impact assessment, revised sewerage impact assessment, revised environmental assessment, revised indicative layout plan and master layout plan (with revised sewerage treatment plant location) and replacement pages of revised landscape proposal. |
|---|---|
| Applicant's Submission | No softcopy provided by Applicant. Hardcopies available at Planning Enquiry Counters for inspection. |
| Decision |
Accepted but Not Exempted from Publication
Newspaper Notice Download newspaper notice Gist Download Gist [Note: The Gist may be superseded by a new Gist if Further Information is received] |
| No. of Comments on Further Information Already Received | 26/07/2022 (15) |
| Nature | The applicant submitted further information, including a table of responses to departmental comments, revised landscape proposal with tree survey schedule, revised environmental assessment, revised sewerage impact assessment, and replacement pages of water supply impact assessment. |
|---|---|
| Applicant's Submission | No softcopy provided by Applicant. Hardcopies available at Planning Enquiry Counters for inspection. |
| Decision |
Accepted but Not Exempted from Publication
Newspaper Notice Download newspaper notice Gist Download Gist [Note: The Gist may be superseded by a new Gist if Further Information is received] |
| No. of Comments on Further Information Already Received | 30/08/2022 (12) |
| Nature | The applicant submitted further information including a table of responses to departmental comments, a revised traffic impact assessment and endorsement letter of traffic forecast methodology for environmental assessment. |
|---|---|
| Applicant's Submission | No softcopy provided by Applicant. Hardcopies available at Planning Enquiry Counters for inspection. |
| Decision |
Accepted but Not Exempted from Publication
Newspaper Notice Download newspaper notice Gist Download Gist [Note: The Gist may be superseded by a new Gist if Further Information is received] |
| No. of Comments on Further Information Already Received | 07/10/2022 (12) |
| Nature | The applicant submitted further information including a table of responses to departmental comments, revised sewerage impact assessment and replacement pages of the environmental assessment. |
|---|---|
| Applicant's Submission | No softcopy provided by Applicant. Hardcopies available at Planning Enquiry Counters for inspection. |
| Decision |
Accepted but Not Exempted from Publication
Newspaper Notice Download newspaper notice Gist Download Gist [Note: The Gist may be superseded by a new Gist if Further Information is received] |
| No. of Comments on Further Information Already Received | 08/11/2022 (23) |
| Nature | The applicant submitted further information including a table of responses to departmental comments, revised public transport assessment of the traffic impact assessment, replacement pages of the environmental assessment, replacement pages of the revised sewerage impact assessment, supplementary figures for transport facilities arrangement and updated rectified landscape plans. |
|---|---|
| Applicant's Submission | No softcopy provided by Applicant. Hardcopies available at Planning Enquiry Counters for inspection. |
| Decision |
Accepted but Not Exempted from Publication
Newspaper Notice Download newspaper notice Gist Download Gist [Note: The Gist may be superseded by a new Gist if Further Information is received] |
| No. of Comments on Further Information Already Received | 06/01/2023 (19) |
| Nature | The applicant submitted further information including a table of responses to departmental comments and replacement pages of the revised environmental assessment. |
|---|---|
| Applicant's Submission | No softcopy provided by Applicant. Hardcopies available at Planning Enquiry Counters for inspection. |
| Decision | Accepted and Exempted from Publication |
| Nature | The applicant submitted further information including consolidated planning statement with technical assessments and response to comment tables. |
|---|---|
| Applicant's Submission | No softcopy provided by Applicant. Hardcopies available at Planning Enquiry Counters for inspection. |
| Decision | Accepted and Exempted from Publication |